Very, very occasionally an exceptional generalist intellectual or particularly well-informed journalist might be able to see a problem with a paper that an academic close to the subject doesn't, but this radically underestimates the uses of expertise/familiarity with a literature
Nate Silver
Nate Silver17.8. klo 23.32
Academic journals might be a lost cause but they'd probably be better if you had some non-academic practitioners serving as reviewers. Journalists have their problems too but they have much better bullshit detectors, for instance.
441,71K